Fabamy's Blog

Crazy life of a CenPho comedian & socialite

Why you shouldn’t cross-post between Twitter & Facebook November 1, 2011

Filed under: Uncategorized — fabamy @ 10:17 am
Tags: , , , ,

Yet another thing that makes me stabby in Social Media Land: Cross-posting between Twitter and Facebook. I don’t mean just for businesses, either. Regular accounts and fan/business pages are included. Here’s why:

1. Facebook and Twitter are completely different. Would you put 22-inch rims on a Mini Cooper? No? Why not? Oh, right. BECAUSE THEY DON’T FIT! The same goes for posts on both Twitter and Facebook. You get 140 characters on Twitter to say your piece. Yes, you can shorten links to pack more punch into your tweets. That’s pretty much it, though. Twitter is for information sharing and engagement one-on-one. You don’t get the thread you get on Facebook. On the other hand, you can post longer things on Facebook for people to comment on and respond to.

2. Not all of your customers/friends are on Twitter, so why would you want your Twitter feed on Facebook? My Mom would go blind seeing all the “@” mentions on her Facebook feed. She’d wonder what the heck she missed and start doing it for everything. She really would. And it wouldn’t make sense. Neither does your Twitter feed being posted on Facebook. Do all your fans/friends know what #FBLT is? How about #FF? No, they don’t, so don’t alienate them.

3. It’s just LAZY. Since content on both platforms NEED to be different, take a few moments to bounce back from one to the other. Really, it only takes a few moments. You can use different programs to post to both, without saying the same thing. I prefer SproutSocial, but I don’t even use it to post to Facebook. I actually log into each account and post individually. It’s my job, right?

4. It makes me stabby and drives those of us who actually know what we’re doing BONKERS. By bonkers I mean that I picture myself as one of those super balls that you bounce on the floor and it hits the ceiling and everything else in the room. That’s how cross-posting makes me feel.

5. If you want people to engage on your Facebook page, why would you post something that doesn’t encourage it? Your #FBLT and #FF tweets do not encourage your customers or friends to converse. It’s word vomit that clogs up your feed and pushes great content lower and lower on your page and then nobody will see it. What’s the point?

6. 90% of the time, it’s just WRONG.


10 Responses to “Why you shouldn’t cross-post between Twitter & Facebook”

  1. carols837 Says:

    Thanks, Amy, cross-posting drives me absolutely wild, too. It had to be said.

  2. Oh it’s a total turnoff. And you can loose fans. According to KissMetrics, the ideal posting on Facebook is one post every two days whereas on Twitter it is one to four posts per hour. Article: http://bit.ly/iCAp1u

    Another good read: Auto-Posting to Facebook Decreases Likes and Comments by 70% http://bit.ly/nefB1w

  3. I meant “lose” fans. Not “loose.”

  4. Hear, Hear! And that goes DOUBLE for those who insist on Tweeting their every movement (OMG!) with Foursquare. In the first place, if wherever it is that they happen to find themselves at the moment is so damned cool that we all need to know, and since they are most likely using some form of smartphone or another, why the hell can’t they at least include a picture to make it somewhat sorta kinda interesting. But the real deal is that, in the second place, nobody actually cares.

  5. […] FabAmy:  Why You Shouldn’t Cross-Post Between Twitter and Facebook […]

  6. […] Mark is a TWC meterologist who is specifically charged with keeping the conversation going. A quick check of his Twitter feed at any time offers a glimpse into the conversation. His latest tweets generally tend to include replies, questions to his followers, and updates on weather events. Mark also maintains a Facebook page that doesn’t cross-post to his Twitter feed (thank you for not cross-posting, by the way). […]

  7. […] clear to social media regulars that you’re lazy. Blogger and stand-up comedian Amy Donohue writes of cross-posting:  “It makes me stabby and drives those of us who actually know what […]

  8. […] FabAmy:  Why You Shouldn’t Cross-Post Between Twitter and Facebook […]

  9. […] FabAmy:  Why You Shouldn’t Cross-Post Between Twitter and Facebook […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s